Critical Opinion: The Force Awakens

There’s no way to understate the scope and scale of the undertaking that faced Disney and Lucasfilm when tasked with bringing Star Wars back to the big screen. With George Lucas retired and the company in the hands of new owners, Kathleen Kennedy and her team faced the mammoth project of not only launching a fresh era of Star Wars – arguably the fifth era after that of the original trilogy, the Dark Times of the late 80’s, the return of Star Wars via Heir to the Empire in the early 90’s and the expansive prequel era – but making it attractive to both old school Generation One fans, those born and bred in the prequel era and all points in between. Sitting here now in 2016, with The Force Awakens™ slotted into Blu-ray and DVD drives across the planet and sitting on a worldwide box office haul of $2,065,342,689, ($935,642,689 of that from North America alone) it’s easy to get cocky and brush its success off as a fait accompli. It was anything but. In a competitive franchise-led landscape the venerable series could have struggled to find its audience. Thankfully, that was not the case.

In my eighth entry in the Critical Opinion series we look at how the professional movie critics here in the UK and across the pond in the States reviewed J.J. Abrams first sequel trilogy entry. Would it be as well received as its predecessors in the 70’s, 80’s, 90’s and 00’s? Let’s find out.

forceawakens_oblog_mn_2

Writing in Variety on 16th December 2015 Justin Chang was certainly charmed by many of the elements which blended to make The Force Awakens such a mega-blockbuster and cultural waypoint.

The Force Awakens feels disarmingly swift and light on its feet, possessed of a comic sensibility that embraces contemporary wisecrackery and earnest humor in equal measure. Shot on 35mm film (plus some 65mm Imax footage), Abrams’ movie has grit under its nails and blood in its veins, as we see in an early battle sequence in which an Imperial Stormtrooper’s white helmet is suddenly streaked with red. A conflicted young warrior-slave who goes by the name of Finn (John Boyega), this Stormtrooper has been brainwashed into serving the First Order — a new army of galactic terrorists that arose from the ashes of the evil Empire, about three decades after the Battle of Endor. Doing battle with the First Order are the good men and women behind a rebel movement called the Resistance.

Noting the clever editing of Maryann Brandon and Mary Jo Markey and the skilled CGI work of ILM Chang also notes that The Force Awakens doesn’t reinvent the wheel, easing fans old and new back into the classic feel of this sequel era.

forceawakens_oblog_mn_3

On 20th December noted UK film critic Mark Kermode set aside his prior disinterest in all things Star Wars and gave Episode 7 a fair shot. Writing in The Guardian the usually Force-proof Kermode melted like thawing carbonite to the charms of the film.

“I have always been the wrong age for Star Wars. When the first trilogy began back in the late 70s, I was old enough to be wedded to the darker, moodier sci-fi of Solaris, Silent Running and Soylent Green, and young enough to believe that gave me the right to dismiss this latterday Buck Rogers nonsense out of hand. When the prequels began at the end of the 90s, I was still young enough to be working for Radio 1 (the station that had overwhelmingly voted Star Wars the greatest movie of all time) but old enough to know that this new series had little of the timeless charm of the originals, about which I remained agnostic.”

Clearly not a fan but The Force Awakens was about to drastically change his mind.

“Now, as Episode VII rolls around, ushering in a new generation of sequels, I find myself at an age so out of whack with the film’s target demographic that what I think about it matters not a jot. Ironic, then, that watching Star Wars: The Force Awakens, I found myself feeling like a 12-year-old, reading for the first time the words: “A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away”, hearing John Williams’s fanfare theme and discovering what all the fuss was about.”

“Discovering what all the fuss was about.” What a treat. Not only seeing a new live action Star Wars film for the first time in a decade but feeling that illusive magic work its charm. He continued…

“What’s most striking about Star Wars: The Force Awakens is the fact that this multimillion dollar franchise blockbuster has real heart and soul. Abrams has always been a fan first, and there’s a palpable affection in his staging of scenes that recall the varied alien wildlife of Tatooine’s Mos Eisley Cantina. Just as he proved himself a worthy successor to Spielberg with Super 8, so Abrams here breathes new life into Lucas’s epochal creations in a manner that deftly looks back to the future. And it’s a future that works. Watching the film in a packed auditorium with an audience almost incandescent with expectation, I found myself listening to a chorus of spontaneous gasps, cheers, laughs, whoops and even occasional cries of anguish.

What’s really surprising is that many of them were coming from me.”

Believe me, take a listen to Kermode and Mayo’s Film Review every Friday between 2.00pm and 4.00pm on BBC Radio Five Live and you’ll see what a huge compliment and turnaround that review is.

forceawakens_oblog_mn_4

Empire Magazine have long been champions of the Star Wars saga, featuring the GFFA on its covers numerous times since the magazines launch back in 1989. Writing on 15th December Helen O’Hara gave the film a glowing recommendation.

“It is unbelievably good to see Han (Harrison Ford) and Chewbacca (Peter Mayhew) back together again — and later rejoin Leia (Carrie Fisher), C-3PO (Anthony Daniels) and the rest. There’s a sense of weight to those relationships that is impossible to fake because the audience is part of the love — to cite a rival franchise, it’s the difference between the emotional heft of The Wrath Of Khan and the emotionless waft of Star Trek Into Darkness. Here too there’s a sense of decades passed and battles lost and won, of old arguments half-healed and old love still simmering.”

O’Hara also throws high praise on the key villain of the piece, Kylo Ren.

“Against them there is Kylo Ren, the best villain that the franchise has ever produced. He’s not just a worthy heir to Vader; he may be more interesting. Rangy to the point of being gangly, there’s the sense of adolescence still clinging to him, his rages coming across as petulant rather than showing Vader’s cold fury. This, you sense, is one messed-up kid — an impression reinforced by his struggle with the “seduction” of the light side. “The First Order rose from the dark side,” says Max von Sydow’s wise man, Lor San Tekka. “You did not.” And yet Ren is casually formidable, freezing a blaster bolt with a wave of his hand and halting opposition with a thought. He has the most interesting arc in the film, even more so than Boyega, and while he will most decidedly not be a fan favourite, he is an astonishing bad guy.

By the end, this finds fresh ingredients to add to the Star Wars formula, strengthening and deepening it.”

forceawakens_oblog_mn_5

Richard Brody writing in The New Yorker was slightly less effusive about the film, pointing to the obviously nostalgic elements of the film but noting the humour and heart on screen.

“The director J. J. Abrams infuses the latest installment of George Lucas’s intergalactic franchise with the spirit of Steven Spielberg in this awestruck, warmhearted, and good-humored action spectacle. It’s centered on the search for Luke Skywalker by the organized Resistance to the evil dominion of the First Order. That oppressive successor to the Empire wants to extinguish the last of the Jedi, whose help the Resistance fighters need. Abrams recruits a remarkable new posse of actors—including Oscar Isaac, John Boyega, Daisy Ridley, and Adam Driver—to play a batch of new characters. Abrams, who co-wrote the script with Lawrence Kasdan and Michael Arndt, stage-manages some breathlessly clever plotting, but he also plays every gesture and every gag, every sigh and every whoop to the balcony, and he milks decades of nostalgia with the stagy entrances of Carrie Fisher, Harrison Ford, and Mark Hamill.“

A tad uncharitable but there’s no denying that those ‘stagy entrances’ were met with whoops of delight and tears of joy by lifelong fans of the saga.

forceawakens_oblog_mn_6

Over at Rolling Stone Peter Travers wrote this glowing review on 16th December, praising the new ‘big three’ of Oscar Isaac, Daisy Ridley and John Boyega.

“Isaac oozes flyboy charm, Boyega, bracingly comic and cunning, is a find, and Ridley (both she and Boyega are Brits) is a star in the making. Rey is the kind of can-do woman of heart and mind who can make a franchise. I’m not just talking marketing. Her scenes with the equally purposeful Leia have a femcentric wit and warmth. The new actors are all aces. But no one can steal a scene from BB-8, a droid who looks like an orange-and-white beach ball on a continuous roll. No one, except for Ford who owns this film from his first crooked grin. If you don’t lose it when Ford’s Han Solo reenters the Millennium Falcon, a hunk of junk he calls a spacecraft, you truly deserve banishment to the dark side. “Chewie, we’re home,” he says. Truer words have never been spoken.”

forceawakens_oblog_mn_7

Manohla Dargis over at The New York Times was equally as impressed, writing on 16th December:

“The big news about “Star Wars: The Force Awakens” is — spoiler alert — that it’s good! Despite the prerelease hype, it won’t save the world, not even Hollywood, but it seamlessly balances cozy favorites — Harrison Ford, ladies and gentlemen — and new kinetic wows, along with some of the niceties that went missing as the series grew into a phenomenon, most crucially a scale and a sensibility that are rooted in the human. It has the usual toy-store-ready gizmos and critters, but it also has appealingly imperfect men and women whose blunders and victories, decency and goofiness remind you that a pop mythology like “Star Wars” needs more than old gods to sustain it.”

forceawakens_oblog_mn_8

Across town Joe Morgenstern, writing on 16th December at The Wall Street Journal praised the film for not only satisfying the existing Star Wars crowd and giving them nostalgic treats aplenty but also for striking out into the new sequel era with style.

“Disney, the new proprietor, and J.J. Abrams, the director, haven’t diluted the appeal of this space opera for the ages. Far from it, “Star Wars: The Force Awakens” flatters old and new audiences alike, and straddles generations with aplomb. “You’re Han Solo?” asks the startled young heroine, Rey, after the gallant old guy has come aboard a battered old spaceship—the Millennium Falcon, of course—that she, a scavenger by trade but also a pilot, has chanced to purloin. (Rey is played, dazzlingly, by Daisy Ridley.) “I used to be,” Han replies with a small, sardonic grin owned solely by Harrison Ford. Rarely have age and shining youth been juxtaposed more affectingly, but that’s only one of many moments of grace in a movie that mines its resonant mythology while moving its story ever forward.”

If nothing else The Force Awakens was keenly aware of its legacy, both on and off-screen and played both to perfection. Morgenstern goes on to praise the new additions to the galaxy.

“Other things have changed in gratifyingly gradual ways. There’s a trashy/raffish version of the Mos Eisley cantina where a begoggled little creature called Maz Kanata (Lupita Nyong’o) dispenses wisdom worthy—well, almost worthy—of Yoda. And though it isn’t correct to say that R2-D2 has been replaced (that goes for Chewie and C-3PO too), another supercute droid, and potential toy bonanza, has rolled on the scene: Rey’s little companion, BB-8, a machine with a body that resembles a beach ball and a head reminiscent of the pedestal of an iMac G5 desktop. Instead of the Death Star there’s Starkiller Base, a far bigger installation on a remote ice planet but similarly vulnerable via an Achilles’ heel that rebel fighter pilots—led by Oscar Isaac’s vibrant Poe Dameron—attack through slot canyons reminiscent of earlier slot canyons while accompanied by a John Williams score that echoes classic “Star Wars” themes, yet remains fresh and hugely helpful.

Everything you need to know about the movie is precisely where it belongs, in the movie. Just see it. You’ll love it.”

forceawakens_oblog_mn_9

We end with a UK review from The Telegraph written by Robbie Collin and published on 18th December.

“This will begin to make things right,” mutters Max von Sydow gravely – and you cast Max von Sydow knowing that’s exactly how he’ll mutter it – in the first earthbound scene of Star Wars: The Force Awakens. The “this” in question is a star-map that reveals the whereabouts of Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill), and you might say that during the events of the last 30 or so years, his presence has been sorely missed. There are moments of drama and excitement here that are pure late-Seventies vintage, although The Force Awakens’ new leads – a young woman and a young black man, neither one an obvious heir to the Skywalker Aryan farm-boy mantle – show that stories set a long time ago in faraway galaxies can still move with the times when it counts.

To describe Kylo Ren as this film’s Vader would be accurate in a sense (black cloak, polished headgear, husky voice). But it would also be to undersell the deep ingenuity with which this astonishing character has been crafted by Abrams, Kasdan and Arndt, and also the wells of emotional tumult Driver invests in him.”

And even a seasoned critic like Collin wasn’t immune to the emotional heft of the story.

“I’ll confess to crying three times during the film: once during Rey and Finn’s escape from Jakku, when I realised that Star Wars was in safe hands, again during one particular Kylo Ren scene which I’ve gone out of my way not to describe above, and also during the climactic lightsaber duel, framed by frozen trees and illuminated by flares of red and blue electricity – which I suspect, on an initial watch, might be the most thrilling battle of its kind to date. You wouldn’t describe the choreography as snazzy, but the dramatic stakes are dizzying. Never mind the spacecraft and explosions. Two beautiful faces in tight close up, dramatically lit and blazing with emotion? That’s what cinema is for.”

He’s not wrong. The Force Awakens dazzles because there’s as much beauty in the small, personal character moments as the sweeping, galaxy-changing ones. Star Wars has always had a knack for balancing the two, giving as much attention to the tiniest gestures as the largest ones. After all, what other film outside of the galaxy far, far away could make you cry with joy, laughter and sorrow like The Force Awakens?

Mark Newbold
Former Daily Content Manager and Program Director for Jedi News and the podcast network (August 2010 to August 2017). Former Co-host RADIO 1138 and Take Cover on the Jedi News Network.